1) Flip Diaper System
pros: cute colors, snaps, one size, wipe out liner, sturdy, organic cotton insert
cons: expensive, not as cute as some others, not plush, could be bulky on infant
style: This is an outer shell with an organic cotton prefold. You just fold the insert, place it inside and snap it on baby. Very easy to wash and dry.
I found the best results with this cd. It sucked in liquid so quickly that it never beaded up at all. it held 2 cups of liquid before it would have leaked out of the leg openings if a baby sat down. Very impressive!
2) Bum Genious All in One
pros: all in one means no added pieces, very simple for dad/babysitter, trim, cute, well respected name, slot to stuff more inserts as needed
cons: velcro(can buy in snaps), doesn't hold as much liquid as others, sized so would need to replace as baby grows (or could buy one size), difficult to dry
style: all in one (no need for inserts), sized diaper. works just like a disposable except you wash and dry it, It does have an opening in the back that you can stuff an insert if you need more absorption like for overnight
I was surprised with the results of this experiment most. This diaper held the least amount of liquid. At around 3/4 cup of water it would have leaked out of the legs if a baby sat down. I was bummed because I really like the style, ease of use with this diaper. I think I would try the other bum genious options though and not just ruke these out entirely.
3) G Diaper
pros: very cute designs, can buy at local stores, not too expensive, can use cloth or disposable inserts
cons: not very well made, a bit flimsy, snap in liner is tiny and you have to work at it to get it to hold the insert just right, sized
style: this is called a hybrid diaper. Its a combo of disposable and cloth. Youo can use disposable inserts that can be flushed if opened up, or you can invest in the cloth inserts which I did not. This experiment is using disposable inserts that look like giant pads.
The result of this test was what I expected. It held about 1 cup of water before it would have leaked. I just can't love this diaper system as much as I wanted to. Its so damn cute, but its just a hassle and not worthy of investing in (in my opinion).
4) Grow Baby
pros: thick nice quality material, very sturdy, plush,cute colors, one size, comfy, liner stays in place due to snaps, can get a nice fit due to lots of elastic
cons: liner can not just be wiped clean due to mesh fabric lining, velcro, expensive, insert not organic
Style: like the Flip System but this has 2 snaps to hold the liner in. The liner is a body shaped cotton with 2 additional inserts to rest on top.
This product held about 1 cup of water. I was hoping it woulkd be equal to the Flip diaper in absorption but it just isn't.
After using each of these diapers for a few months, and looking at the results of the experiment I'm not sure which system I would invest in if given the choice. The G diaper is definately out of the running for me. The Flip has awesome absorbing power but its just not as comfy as the gro baby. I think I would try other Bum Genious diapers since that has a lot of nice qualities. They now come in organic and have different styles to choose from.